Try the free LITEROTICA WEBCAMS!

‘gay anal first time’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
gay anal first time 

Category

Sort by:
ViewsRatingFavoriteNewest
All Time

Taken for the First Time Ch. 01

An older man takes a willing first timer all the way.

by CandleLit in Gay Male 04/17/2015
H
4.65
463.9k
419
111
519

Brotherly Love

Two brothers acknowledge their love for each other.

by datura48 in Incest/Taboo 09/19/2017
4.48
72.7k
92
7
146
0

Born to Suck Ch. 14

Sven works over Joey's virginal ass all night long.

by rmdexter in Gay Male 12/05/2010
H
4.68
117k
68
4
76

Big Bot, Sex Hot, Breeder Gets Laid

Sex-starved guy gives in to gay colleague's desire.

by danielblue in Gay Male 10/14/2005
4.45
164k
62
0
77
0

Tyler, My Brother, and Me Ch. 04

I resign myself to losing my virginity to Tyler.

by datura48 in Gay Male 05/03/2018
H
4.61
42.2k
58
5
74

A New Awakening

Ben takes a young man under his wing.

by PhantomOfMoonlight in Gay Male 12/23/2010
4.48
57.8k
23
4
31
0

Frankie Takes My Anal Virginity

Girlfriend’s father gives me my first ass screwing!

by Bi_Siamese in Gay Male 01/20/2021
4.39
31.8k
23
3
52
0

Memories of a Lustful Youth

A brief summary of sexual exploits of a young man 'learning'.

by Giganet in Gay Male 10/27/2017
H
4.5
34.9k
7
3
11
0

First Real Man Ch. 02

He follows him into the bedroom.

by kokshur in Gay Male 11/03/2012
4.09
40.8k
6
0
6
Active tags
Active tags
gay anal first time
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ

Category filter