‘gay first time’ stories
Active tags
Active tags
The Bet
Straight guy loses a bet at a gay bar.
Rest Area
Man experiences his first cock at a rest stop.
First & Only
He remembers the first and only time with another man.
Overpowered
How an athletic 25-year-old took control of me at age 18.
Pretty Boy
Spoiled narcissist hates his macho football jock roommate.
Truth or Dare
Two straight friends get dared to try something new.
Gorgeous
He deflowers a very special virgin.
Trapped
Two straight guys trapped in the snow do what they must.
Separate tags with commas. More info in the
FAQ