‘gay first time’ stories

An older married straight man gives up his anal cherry.

A knock on the door leads to an intense afternoon experience.

College guy continues exploring gay sex with lots of cum.

An unsuspecting traveler gets a massage he won't forget.

A fantasy of an older man being seduced into gay sex.

Young bachelor gets the urge for cock.

Matt's first time is in the gym shower.

18-year-old virgin is chosen for service to the high lord.

My first time trolling for trouser trout.

A muscled straight military guy lets me have him.

It started with a tail...

Little did they know they were helping each other.

Jack's brazenness leads me to break down barriers.

Straight cowboy needs a man.

First gay male experience directed by Michelle.

Actually he gets ridden again.

Seamus takes his best-friend's virginity.

The doctor gets an exam.

Will Chad and Blaine get their happily ever after?

Everyone gains and loses from a poker party.

18 year old guy gets picked up by older guy.

Mark and Deacon try to enjoy the last of their time together.

Short story about me getting my cherry popped finally.

A 50-year-old man gets a second.

Alcohol + porn store = first gay blowjob.

Mick learns about sex from an upperclassman.

Divorced guy on vacation is seduced by younger man.

19-year-old has his first gay experience in a movie theater.

I suck a cock for the first time

Jacob & Mr D go it alone - a first time for them both.

Conversion by mistaken impression.

The horse-hung stud dominates two teammates in the shower.

Stranger comes to the aid of a stranded young traveler.

He remembers the first and only time with another man.

Teasing a friend has surprising results.

Matt tries to make things right with Jake, but he wants Dave.

Friendship between two guys turns sexual.

Guy has first gay sexual experience in sex shop.

First time in the hot tub.

I Decided to Act on my fantasies for Cocks.

An exgirlfriend wants to finally see me with a man.

The great barbarian shows another side.

I discover that I like the taste of another man's cock.

College guy leaves home & gets his first blowjob.

Ray and Jase kick their explorations up a notch.

Bi-curious guy visits his first gay sauna.

Marrried man discovers men.

Young dude tops a jock for the first time.

Two straight, married, muscle jocks spend a naked weekend...

College friends get close on a island getaway.

Man submits to curiosity and find his submissive side.

This is a story of my first time sucking a man.

My buddy and I unleashed next-level sex on each other.

Mature male finds gay lifestyle.

His introduction to gay sex.

Perry loses his cherry to a football jock on a camping trip.

A true story about a young man's first gay encounters.

Coaxing down the barriers.

The story of my first time with another guy.

A story of male bisexual enlightenment.

A boy heads into the woods to find the truth of his nature.

Meredith guides you along your first homosexual experience.

A colleague finally gets to seduce you.

He loved women, but desired men too.

A night-shift mechanic gives in to temptation.

A straight boy's fantasy is fulfilled, for a small price.

Rower studs bet on who has the biggest dick.

How receptive athletes are seduced at team physicals.

A divorced man explores further with his gay roommate.

A platonic friendship changes to be more.

A desperate straight guy decides to seduce a workmate.

Two friends wonder about Saturday.

A young "straight" man has a new experience.

Injured guy gets a little help from another man.

New employee finds his place.

While bored on summer break, two friends get closer.

Two men explore their bisexuality.

Man finds friend jerking off and is changed forever.

Young adult has gay experience.

My 21st birthday begins with a new experience.

Friend's cock lingers in his thoughts, comes out as husband.

Caught trespassing, Clark uses Randy's mouth to get out.

David tries bi-sex.

Paul's first real blow-job and anal sex.

Fulfillment of my wife's fantasy of her boyfriend and me.

18 yr old Billy lives with his Uncle Tom in remote Oregon.

What can happen when you go for an evening swim.

A story about a gay first time between friends.

Teen on the road needs a friend after heartbreak.

New to Los Angeles, a teenager is seduced by an older man.

Curious guy's first time gay - and it had to be big!

Two guys help each other out at a training session.

Training a teenage recruit.

Discovering the joy of cock play leads to fulfillment.

A gay male story.

Mel gets more comfortable with his body.

Moving in with sis & her roomie offers new experiences.

A young man learns the joys of gay sex.

Tom learns that love doesn't always follow the rules.

Was my brother kidding me?