‘high school crush’ stories

Future faculty member meets a cute co-ed and a hot professor.

Kimber reconnects with an old crush.

Emotional events trigger close friends to become even more.

Oliver's high school crush visits Las Vegas & sparks fly.

Having nothing to live for made him a dangerous man.

A simple story of a simple trucker and his unfaithful wife.

Adam turns Tyler's world upside-down. Can Tyler resist?

Julie and I go on a sexually charged trip after reconnecting.

Another man's wife stole his jelly beans and his heart.

Will a lustful weekend deliver a valentine?

Two lost opportunities reimagined.

Susie seduces Bruce by asking for pictures.

Grown Woman Fucks Her High School Crush.

My Panties-Fetish made me Pussy-Stuck Forever.

These climaxes had been building for twenty-five years.

Mystery Revealed & Best Date Ever with Lisa.

He reunites and falls in love with his old high school crush.

A reunion fantasy - or is it?

A high school crush hangs on over the years.

Running into a high school crush at a bar.

A woman gets gangbanged at her high school reunion.

A dirty prison, a wounded girl, and a boy who cares.

What better way to impress your crush than a gangbang.

Young man loses virginity to two girls.

High School Crush stays the night.

It's hard to let go of your first love.

A careless wife burns herself.

She gives in to the desire she still feels for you.

Two ladies manipulate an attorney to get the terms they want.

Lost my virginity to my High School crush.

The baby shower might have been different.

An old classmate ran into his fat booty chocolate crush.

A store manager has a reunion with his high school crush.