Try the free LITEROTICA WEBCAMS!

‘old crush’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
old crush 

Category

Sort by:
ViewsRatingFavoriteNewest
30 DaysAll Time

Easter at St. Michael's Ch. 03

Gordon is reunited with an old crush.

by Blacksheep in Erotic Couplings 04/02/2024
H
4.53
1.5k
2
0
5

To Quench Our Love Pt. 01

Alone in a new town, I happen to run into someone I know.

by SliceofSomething in Romance 11/23/2022
H
4.71
5.6k
8
4
24

Emily

Finding an old crush.

by whatep in Romance 01/26/2022
H
4.67
10.7k
9
8
20
0

The Girl Next Door

Reunion with old crush leading to a steamy night sex.

by jewelalyssa in Erotic Couplings 11/21/2020
3.93
13.3k
2
0
4
0

My Wicked Ways Bk. 02 Ch. 01 - A New Dawn

Beginning of the follow-up story after the apocalypse.

by SEVERUSMAX in NonHuman 07/25/2018
H
4.5
9.7k
10
3
19

Passion Takes Over

Reuniting with an old crush.

by LiteralEroticKink in Erotic Couplings 06/22/2016
4.11
13.2k
1
2
2
0

Modern Day Cavegirls - Dirty Love

Are you trying to seduce my kid sister?

by TaLtos6 in Lesbian Sex 09/28/2015
H
4.75
21k
21
6
26

The Reunion

Fantasy turns hot reality after 10 long years.

by MissCheriBomb in Erotic Couplings 02/14/2010
3.91
23.8k
5
1
7
0

Rainy Day Surprise

A Fantasy becomes reality one rainy afternoon.

by libkeg in Loving Wives 05/28/2007
3.7
79.1k
2
0
7
0
Active tags
Active tags
old crush
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ