‘shy’ stories

Active tags
first time (74)wife (70)virgin (66)college (59)blowjob (53)cunnilingus (43)masturbation (43)public (43)oral (38)female virgin (38)voyeur (37)romance (37)reluctant (35)anal (34)female masturbation (33)lesbian (30)student (30)pussy eating (28)nude (28)older man (27)coed (26)innocent (26)seduction (26)younger woman (26)female submissive (25)humiliation (25)stranger (25)love (25)exhibitionism (24)friends (24)brunette (24)exhibitionist (24)blonde (24)threesome (23)blow job (22)male dominant (21)spanking (20)teasing (20)teacher (19)cuckold (19)group sex (19)18-year-old (18)fantasy (18)romantic (18)sauna (18)petite (17)forced (16)true love (16)strip (16)cheating (16)mature (15)teen (15)group (15)handjob (15)fingering (14)redhead (14)panties (14)party (14)bdsm (14)outdoors (14)voyeurism (14)milf (14)girlfriend (14)mutual masturbation (13)asian (13)orgasm (13)interracial (13)indian (13)her first time (13)creampie (13)kissing (13)embarrassed (12)submission (12)tease (12)shower (12)exposed (12)watching (12)lesbian first time (12)submissive (12)slut (12)school (12)nudist (12)big cock (12)younger man (11)mdom (11)spa (11)older woman (11)white (11)cum (11)naked (11)bikini (11)incest (11)male masturbation (11)big tits (10)roommate (10)oral sex (10)reluctance (10)professor (10)public sex (10)tits (10)fellatio (10)black man (10)femdom (10)co-worker (9)male virgin (9)husband (9)india (9)nudity (9)ffm (9)vacation (9)office (9)nerd (9)big breasts (9)lonely (9)chinese (9)non-con (8)small breasts (8)bbw (8)doctor (8)tiny tits (8)massage (8)double penetration (8)swingers (8)drunk (8)black (8)noncon (8)sister (7)taboo (7)lingerie (7)slave (7)inexperienced (7)mmf (7)curved cock (7)vibrator (7)beach (7)flashing (7)dildo (7)friend (7)rough (7)model (7)solo (7)son (7)escort (7)vampire (7)timid (7)neighbor (7)couple (7)young (7)awakening (6)crush (6)busty (6)library (6)hotel (6)car (6)orgy (6)gangbang (6)shaved (6)swinging (6)work (6)schoolgirl (6)high school (6)panty (6)public nudity (6)horny (6)secretary (6)summer (6)rough sex (6)enf (6)photo (6)long legs (6)topless (6)straight (6)outside (5)brother (5)control (5)island (5)college girl (5)master (5)black woman (5)hairy (5)birthday (5)power aura (5)poker (5)bisexual (5)adultery (5)erotic (5)mom (5)neighbors (5)boss (5)breasts (5)facial (5)nipples (5)blackmail (5)gay (5)masturbate (5)lust (5)toys (5)female orgasm (5)bondage (5)domination (5)love story (5)feet (5)cfnm (5)female dominant (5)mother (5)white woman (5)dare (5)novella (5)dominant (5)dorm (5)switzerland (5)wedding (5)camera (5)transformation (5)no panties (5)conservative (4)caught (4)sex (4)cheat (4)cum swallowing (4)kiss (4)dominance (4)daddy (4)couples (4)strangers (4)catholic (4)exhibition (4)modest (4)embarrassment (4)jealousy (4)werewolf (4)butt plug (4)married (4)

Who's Really in Charge Here? Ch. 01

Isabelle takes Elliot's virginity.

First Time 06/14/2019

Lessons in Love Ch. 04

Morning erection.

Romance 06/14/2019

Mary's Makeover

Shy eighteen-year-old girl gets body makeover.

First Time 06/08/2019

Red Canna Massage Parlor Room 01

38 year old shy virgin wants a deep tissue massage from Mila.

First Time 06/05/2019

Grace the 40 Year Old Virgin Ch. 03

An aging prudish hottie gets her boundaries challenged.

NonConsent/Reluctance 06/04/2019

Kavitha's Injection

Shy wife tells husband how she got a shot in her bottom.

NonConsent/Reluctance 05/30/2019


Above pulled Wendy in. A remarkable experience.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 05/24/2019

Candor Ends Paranoia

You have to be your true self even if your a freak.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 05/10/2019

Room Service Help Photoshoot Ch. 01

Hotel room service help couple photoshoot.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 05/09/2019

Kristen Tests Her Boundaries

Reserved wife accepts her husband's challenge, and her own.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 05/09/2019

Shy Indian Wife's Humiliating Exam

Husband watches as wife is forced to get an immigration exam.

NonConsent/Reluctance 05/02/2019

Natalie is a Work of Art Pt. 01

A young art teacher is taken out of her sexual comfort zone.

Erotic Couplings 04/23/2019

Sex Resort for Rich Gentlemen Ch. 03

OMG she thinks, my dentist saw me fucking. He wants me.

Erotic Couplings 04/22/2019

Sultan Karim and the Royal Harem

Karim enjoys the pleasures of his consort, Kotoko.

Fetish 04/20/2019

Wilde Harem Pt. 01: Home Sweet Home Ch. 02

Ch 2: A Step-Mom's Enticing Offer.

Incest/Taboo 04/13/2019

New Roommate Pt. 02

They talk that evening and have a more intimate encounter.

Lesbian Sex 04/12/2019

Not a Thing to Wear

Some fun nakey and sexy times in a clothing store.

Lesbian Sex 04/12/2019

A Twink, Chatting to Fucking

Virgin twink finds a stranger in a gay chat and gets fucked.

Gay Male 04/12/2019

New Roommate Pt. 01

Her roommate admits she has to masturbate five times a day.

Lesbian Sex 04/04/2019

Sex Resort for Rich Gentlemen Ch. 02

Shy, inexperienced Susan gets enough nerve to go outside.

Group Sex 04/03/2019

One Neighbor Ch. 06

We introduce Pamela to our lawn boy.

NonConsent/Reluctance 03/31/2019

April Fool's Sushi

Ann helps her new roommate Linda to feel more comfortable.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 03/24/2019

Please Sensei

When sensei takes his pants off, she takes her chance.

NonHuman 03/16/2019

Our Sisterhood of the Panties

Close friends get closer through masturbation.

Toys & Masturbation 03/13/2019

Marlyn Sheds Her Inhibitions

Filipina girlfriend learns to let go.

Interracial Love 03/03/2019

Unintended Consequences Ch. 02

A boy, a loyal wife, and an overheard conversation.

Loving Wives 02/23/2019

One Neighbor Ch. 04

Pamela's dad almost catches us.

Loving Wives 02/21/2019

Unintended Consequences

A wife talks dirty unaware that a boy is listening in.

Loving Wives 02/19/2019

One Neighbor Ch. 02

I have to live up to my part of the bargain with my wife.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 02/13/2019

Lisa's Huge Purse Pt. 01

Shy blond spills contents of her purse on the basketball court.

Romance 02/06/2019

Cascade Fire Ch. 03

Caldera | Bob finally finds safe harbor. Between volcanoes.

Mind Control 02/01/2019

Shy Girlfriend Fucked Hard

Loving sex with shy girlfriend.

Erotic Couplings 01/27/2019

Under the Spotlight

A couple takes to the stage to out-swing a swingers club.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 01/18/2019

Mind Control Harem Ch. 01: CumKitty

A hypnotized college girl finds something more.

Romance 01/14/2019

Leopard's Tale: Extra Credit

She will do anything to pass my class.

BDSM 01/05/2019

Korrupting Kayla Pt. 01

Shy, innocent teen is corrupted by her family and friends.

NonConsent/Reluctance 01/05/2019

Sharing Jill Ch. 03

A shy wife continues her adventures with other men.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 01/03/2019

Teaching the Cub Ch. 01 - Introduction

A painfully shy virgin meets an experienced cougar.

First Time 01/03/2019

A F*ck For a Shy, Submissive Girl

He tells of how a shy girl submits herself.

Text With Audio 01/03/2019

My Shy Wife Exposed for a Weekend

A modest wife submits to public display as his birthday gift.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 12/29/2018

Foreign Exchange

A local girl makes a reserved foreign boy feel like a man.

Erotic Couplings 12/28/2018


A man and a woman make a home together.

Erotic Couplings 12/26/2018


A shy college exchange student tries her first two-guy sex.

Erotic Couplings 12/25/2018

Lemon Combo Point

A shy soccer girl gathers her courage for a topless hazing.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 12/24/2018

Young Girl's Gradual Foray Ch. 03

Nisha exposed in her own house.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 12/23/2018


Abby is excited for her first day of college.

Erotic Couplings 12/13/2018

Promotional Photos

Having some promotional photos taken... but promoting what?

Illustrated 12/11/2018

Secret Cove Ch. 02

Jim and Tracy continue the new experiences later that evening.

NonConsent/Reluctance 12/11/2018

Secret Cove

A proper wife finds a new side to herself on a trip.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 12/08/2018

My Neighbor

Doing things with my neighbor.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 11/07/2018

Appointment Ch. 02

He really was a little shy.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 10/28/2018

Nora's Naked Day Ch. 01

Nora tries something new, and is met with humiliating risk.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 10/26/2018

19 Cute Kiss Scenes (Role Reversal)

19 hot places to kiss him or cute types of kiss to receive!

Romance 10/20/2018

Sara's Embarrassing Morning (ENF)

An embarrassing prank leaves Sara in need of cover.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 10/15/2018

Work Love Triangle Pt. 01

A young bartender hooks up with a coworker.

Erotic Couplings 10/08/2018

There Goes the Neighborhood Ch. 03

Kyle makes some noise with the school librarian.

Erotic Couplings 10/05/2018

A Cold Autumn Busride to The Past

A busride brings back fond memories.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 09/26/2018

Birthday Treat

A visit to HK.

Incest/Taboo 09/18/2018

To Fuck My Own Daughter

Clay bonds with his shy daughter by showing her how to fuck.

Incest/Taboo 09/06/2018

My Boyfriend Offers Me to His Bro

I would do anything for my teen sweetheart. Even that.

Group Sex 09/04/2018

An Office Slut Denied

A shy office worker misses a text and must pay the price.

BDSM 08/16/2018

Lost at Sea Bk. 01 Ch. 07

A sexy pirate fantasy adventure, Chapter 7.

Sci-Fi & Fantasy 08/09/2018

Lost at Sea Bk. 01 Ch. 06

A sexy pirate fantasy adventure, Chapter 6.

Sci-Fi & Fantasy 08/08/2018

Day of Firsts

Unexpected encounter.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 07/24/2018

N.I.P - Nina In Public

A camgirl tries to make her first public nudity video clip.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 07/04/2018

Breakthrough Pt. 02

A first!

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 06/22/2018

Fresh Teen Hired for Sex Resort Ch. 01

She needed tuition money for teacher's college and liked it.

Erotic Couplings 06/19/2018

Immersion Therapy Pt. 04

The immersion therapy is coming to a climax.

Group Sex 06/14/2018

The Trip Pt. 01

Ruth finds a guide and driver.

Novels and Novellas 06/12/2018

Immersion Therapy

Shy virgin guy is subjected to unorthodoxed therapy.

NonConsent/Reluctance 06/06/2018

Taming of Fear Pt. 07

After hours.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 05/31/2018

Breakthrough Pt. 01

Unexpected birthday surprise!

Incest/Taboo 05/31/2018

Pretty Young Thing Pt. 03

Nicole recalls her first time.

First Time 05/26/2018

Taming of Fear Pt. 06

German spa.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 05/18/2018

At a Music Festival

I get talked into crowd surfing at an outdoor EDM fest.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 05/17/2018

My Best Buddy

My girlfriend helps my best friend with his shyness.

First Time 05/17/2018

Bare As You Dare

My bf gets me to enter a bare as you dare contest at a bar.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 05/15/2018

Love Street Ch. 02

"Do you think I could have a turn now?" Mary asks.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 04/11/2018

An After Hours Fling

Lola finally gets her shy new boyfriend to fuck her.

Erotic Couplings 04/06/2018

Sis and I and a Private Nude Dancer

Erotic action after bachelorette party at the strip club.

Incest/Taboo 04/05/2018

My Time with Roni - Adventures Ch. 01

Roni scores a Hat-trick.

Group Sex 04/04/2018

My Time with Roni - Submission Ch. 02

Roni, Mason and Me, and a cabin.

Group Sex 04/03/2018

My Time with Roni - Submission - The Retest

Roni asked for a re-test, who was I to refuse.

Erotic Couplings 03/31/2018

My Time with Roni - Submission Ch. 01

Roni's First real Bi-sexual, and total, Submission.

Group Sex 03/30/2018

My Time with Roni - Awakening Ch. 02

The end of the Beginning: Roni's inner Slut wakes up.

Erotic Couplings 03/28/2018

Fun at the Library

Fun in a public library.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 03/27/2018

Hands on the Wheel Ch. 01

Nothing lost in translation.

Loving Wives 03/27/2018

My Time with Roni - Awakening Ch. 01

A story of my beginning with Roni.

Erotic Couplings 03/26/2018

By His Reputation Ch. 04

Alexander and Kate get ready for a night out.

BDSM 03/25/2018

Taming of Fear Pt. 05

The trip.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 03/10/2018

Daniel and Aubrey

A story about two shy eighteen-year-old high school seniors.

First Time 03/08/2018

The App

What happens when immovable nerd meets unstoppable sex tool.

Mind Control 03/06/2018

Taming of Fear Pt. 04

The visit.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 03/06/2018

Taming of Fear Pt. 03

Losing it!

First Time 03/01/2018

Little Luna

Innocent girl meets an internet friend for the first time.

First Time 02/24/2018

Taming of Fear Pt. 02

First date!

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 02/23/2018

Taming of Fear Pt. 01

A breakthrough!

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 02/20/2018

The Wife's Journey

A bored wife cares for an elderly gentleman with a secret.

Mature 02/17/2018

The Interview

Naive Freshman learns something new.

First Time 02/11/2018

Defloration Ch. 02

A shy young girl seeks Paul's help to pop her cherry.

First Time 02/07/2018
Active tags
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ
Related Tags