‘mistaken identity’ stories

Francine Plans a Surprise.

Horny headmaster threatens Mandy's Parisian education.

Mark finds his lesbian sister nude and blindfolded.

There couldn't be a mix up with the costumes - could there?

The Visitation; Hannah receives Holy communion.

Accidentaly fucking my aunt, and my mom thinks I am dad.

He fulfills her fantasy - or does he?

Hollie is mistaken for a student.

She meant to surprise her husband.

Exploring some taboos.

Father, Daughter bonding on a roadtrip.

Mistaken identity leads to an unexpected coupling.

Mistake yields pleasant surprise.

Man with amnesia satisfies retired ladies.

Lucy and her best friend play a trick on her Dad.

Step-Dad lets daughter think he's someone else.

Halloween costume party leads to mistaken identity.

Helping my drunk neighbor back to her bed has its benefits.

Blindfolded guy thinks it's his girlfriend, but...

Mr. Marcus sends Zeke as substitute to party in costume.

A case of mistaken identity.

Mother and son unknowingly meet at a party.

Accident happens when two siblings share a hotel room.

Mother and Daughter unknowingly fall in love while online.

How she accidentally gave her husband's boss a blow job.

My brother is a jerk, so why does he get a smoking hot girl?

Wife sends house guest into my bed.

Step daughter Takes Over.

Costume change makes for my treat at Halloween party.

Velvet didn't expect me home early.

A case of mistaken identity, then brother pushes his luck.

I got a great present and more.

Bella and her daddy have a Halloween party accident.

18-year-olds exploit possibility of mistaken identity.

Mom should stay sober!

Horny drunk girl mistakes her brother for her boyfriend.

Sally trades places with her sister.

Wife finds out he's an author; he find out she's a fan.

Handmaiden versus Tusken Raiders!

A compulsive liar fights to break herself out of her lies

A randy dad slips it in the wrong hole.

Sex. Blackmail. More blackmail. More sex. Happy ending.

Found my mom at a swing club.

She makes a startling discovery.

Mistaken identity leads Maria's sister to get pounded.

Brother's plan to get back at sis succeeds big-time.

Evil woman creates an incest situation

A costume deception leads to new experiences.

He gets mistaken for his sister! Disaster ensues!

She's intriqued by Trek fans, but they go too far.

An irresistible blonde wife left alone.

Intentional exposure again has unexpected consequences.

She gets schooled by her boyfriend's father.

Tutor is lured to a party she knew to avoid.

Even under-the-table jobs have benefits.

A few changes and would his wife know him?

Taken at the club.

She becomes a secret toy at a party.

Surprising events when a friend's son stayed at our house.

Sometimes animal instincts takeover - even when it's mom.

Casandra and Madison switch places.

An April Fool's joke takes an unexpected turn.

Maybe blondes really do have more fun.

At first he loved her, but now he just wants to fuck :)

Vengeance is a killer.

"Scare" was in the air..

Father-in-law doesn't know it's her.

Young sexy wife seduces wrong man.

Swinger party with a twist.

Mistaken for brother's slutty wife.

Stepmom sent back to school.

Schoolteacher's mistaken identity / stranger fantasy begins.

busty scientist becomes lab animal in her own experiment.

A bunk bed, a mischievous roommate and a unsuspecting GF.

Dynamite Twins.

My best friend's wife gets drunk and crashes on my couch.

She went to fuck an old flame....didn't she?

Massage goes too far, and a woman must be satisfied.

A costume party, a wrong address, a case of mistaken ID.

How far will Joelle go to save her college career?

A young man makes a daring move on his crush.

A son takes advantage of his mother blindfolded on her bed.

Son in disguise tricks his alcoholic mother into having sex.

Life is full of surprises.

A double switch!

Sis gets inspired by KISS song after seeing bro with panties.

Mistaken Identity.

Casandra and Madison switch places.

Gypsy grants him sexual luck, but at what cost?

She dresses as Freddy Krueger to pick up girls.

She gets a trick, I get a treat and we both get a nightmare.

A change of stockings leads to unwitting incest.

Avoiding deep valleys of despair...

The Magic Show : how it all began.

Costume party makes man question his sexuality.

Rochelle's mistake is going to cost her dearly.

An elderly man mistakes his daughter for his wife.

Miscommunication has deeper meaning for a lonely mother...

An industrial baron is tricked into something fun.

What happens in Vegas stays in Vegas. Or does it?