‘mistaken identity’ stories

The Unconquered meets his Agate - fourth among his harem!

A medieval fantasy filled with love, lust and treachery.

Sometimes you get what you wish for.

She found him, lost him, but he didn't get far.

A single dad meets an extra-friendly preschool teacher.

(but not in the bagging area...)

A Regency romance of mistaken identity.

A sexy high school teacher is caught in a web of sin.

Mistaken identity, a cop, a victim.

Debbie decides to use sex to earn money.

Things go wrong when twin sisters switch places.

FINAL: Trapped and naked, Jeannie's mistaken identity fantasy.

Peter gets a surprise.

Gina pranks fiancé, but can't stop what she set in motion.

The neighbor's cock is just too good to resist!

Into the mountains...

Discovery & his sister... finally!

Gloryhole revisisted.

Do not trust the genie in the bottle.

Becky, Brody, & the cowboys' brothel.

The MILF next-door mistakes you for your dad from behind.

To get her man, Penny competes with a naked girl.

Don has Sex on the Beach; Alice and cousin play; fucking Meg.

Jeannie discovers light bondage and stranger fantasy.

Time to talk.

A billionaire, a thief, an abduction, and a kiss...

Mother and Son play truth or dare in front of her friends.

The thrilling conclusion of Lucy's incredible adventure!

Transformed into a female, Sara has to adapt to her new life.

Dad finally finds out the truth.

Late night drunk girl neighbour visits.

Sister helps son and mother grow close once more.

Now a Lewis lookalike takes advantage of his life…sorta?

Son masquerades in Dad's costume to fuck unsuspecting Mother.

A Halloween party costume change becomes interesting.

A straight girl accidentally has sex with her own sister.

Christine gets more than she bargained for. A lot more.

How does one recover?

Bro/sis accidental hookup.

Vegas Vacation!

Mandy begins to lose control as situations escalate.

A crush, a friend, and a bachelorette.

Surprised sleeping in Daddy's bed.

The masquerade ball.

Son unwittingly purchases his mother in an auction.

Brother and sister, but didn't know it.

Mixup!

Has the absconded con man been caught?

A man is mistaken for a lingerie salesman by a busty woman.

Trevor's day worsens.

Jason received a mysterious invitation to a masquerade ball.

Shrodinger's Cat: In the dark, all kitties are the same color.

She loves him, but he loves...

Will investigates: love, lust, and a confrontation.

He picks up a strange girl, but she isn't what he thought.

Sophie counts on mistaken identity to get laid at the party.

The party's pitch black, and it could be anyone...

A neighboring party goes wrong and Vic reaps the benefits.

I pick up a girl and discover to my delight she's a shemale.

Something's gotta give.

A simple case of mistaken identity starts it all.

Toxic affair ends and he finds comfort with his sister.

Young man falls for an anonymous lover, but who is she?

A mom mistakes her son for a stanger and puts on a sex show.

Who snuck into Danny's bed?

He went to my tent by mistake, and I didn't stop him.

Mistaken Identity (Be careful what you grab in Produce).

Sister moves in temporarily.

Gay virgin mistakes her for a man.

Edward sees Janice in a new light.

So many girls...but who could it be?

A mistaken identity at a Halloween party leads to more.

A woman is attacked while walking home from a night out.

Straight law student accidentally becomes lesbian prostitute.

The beginning of the end, and a revelation.

Lewis finds that there’s even more of him about.

A brother and sister make a discovery.

Sean fulfills his younger sister's cyberslut fantasies.

In the dark of night a young woman's dream comes true.

Emma's bondage plan for Abigail goes a bit wrong.

Redhead finds excitement and confusion online.

Will freaks out in the aftermath of Sarah's wedding

Man strip searched and more in a case of mistaken identity.

Surprised by his little sister at work.

Another dangerous wager on fidelity.

She disguises herself as a guy - and finds true love.

Daughter pretends to be mom at a costume party.

Felix attempts to stop his sister from making a mistake.

A blind date gone wrong has got worse. But every cloud...

Young girl meets her father for the first time.

Longtime friends fall in love.

Brother in costume fucks all 3 of his bitch sister's holes.

Accepted as a schoolgirl.

Hannah meets her father for the first time.

Sally plots incestuous revenge on her twin sister.

Waylon's story continues.

Craigslist post makes for an interesting situation.

Charlie corrects Mrs. Hendricks' first time.

Darren's sister and her friends stay the week.

Thoughtful considerations followed by fucking Ruth.