‘mistaken identity’ stories

A brother and sister make a discovery.

Son masquerades in Dad's costume to fuck unsuspecting Mother.

Mother and Son play truth or dare in front of her friends.

Brother in costume fucks all 3 of his bitch sister's holes.

Drunken mom makes a huge mistake.

A son walks in on his mother wearing only an apron.

A simple case of mistaken identity starts it all.

Son unwittingly purchases his mother in an auction.

Daughter pretends to be mom at a costume party.

Mother and son unknowingly meet at a party.

A mistaken identity at a Halloween party leads to more.

Darren's sister and her friends stay the week.

Accident happens when two siblings share a hotel room.

A man is mistaken for a lingerie salesman by a busty woman.

A straight girl accidentally has sex with her own sister.

Horny drunk girl mistakes her brother for her boyfriend.

The party's pitch black, and it could be anyone...

He went to my tent by mistake, and I didn't stop him.

Bella and her daddy have a Halloween party accident.

In the dark of night a young woman's dream comes true.

Costume change results in mistaken identity.

A single dad meets an extra-friendly preschool teacher.

Brother and sister accidentally meet in a dark room.

She found him, lost him, but he didn't get far.

Hollie is mistaken for a student.

Man has accidental sex with his stepdaughter.

Beth's father doesn't remember who his wife is.

Helping my drunk neighbor back to her bed has its benefits.

A son takes advantage of his mother blindfolded on her bed.

Mark finds his lesbian sister nude and blindfolded.

I couldn’t resist such a wonderful temptation.

My costumed partner wasn't who she seemed...

Sean fulfills his younger sister's cyberslut fantasies.

Felix attempts to stop his sister from making a mistake.

Mistaken for brother's slutty wife.

Man accidentally rapes his girlfriends twin sister

A Halloween party costume change becomes interesting.

She meant to surprise her husband.

Mom's friend helps college son fuck her.

Discovery & his sister... finally!

Sometimes animal instincts takeover - even when it's mom.

Evil woman creates an incest situation

Mother & father unknowingly arrange a date with their son.

John accidently has sex with his own flesh and blood.

A mom mistakes her son for a stanger and puts on a sex show.

A Regency romance of mistaken identity.

He takes advantage of Natalie's case of mistaken identity.

Miscommunication leads to mistaken fucking.

So many girls...but who could it be?

How does one recover?

Hannah meets her father for the first time.

Father, Daughter bonding on a roadtrip.

Twin siblings join their parents' party.

Mistaken identity leads to rough & tumble lust.

Accidentaly fucking my aunt, and my mom thinks I am dad.

Costume change makes for my treat at Halloween party.

A randy dad slips it in the wrong hole.

Woman with Santa fetish fulfills fantasy, & her nephew's too!

She sucks guy she mistakes as her husband at crowded airport.

Young man falls for an anonymous lover, but who is she?

Ryan's friends trick him into fucking his younger sister.

Bro/sis accidental hookup.

Father of the bride makes daughter his slut.

Gina pranks fiancé, but can't stop what she set in motion.

A few changes and would his wife know him?

Mom should stay sober!

Mistaken identity shows daughter that Daddy's cock is best.

Mistaken identity, a cop, a victim.

My roommate's girlfriend gives me a blowjob by mistake.

18-year-olds exploit possibility of mistaken identity.

Shy wife makes orgy-sized mistake

Brother and sister, but didn't know it.

Mom and Aunt must act to save him.

Another dangerous wager on fidelity.

Surprised by his little sister at work.

My best friend's wife gets drunk and crashes on my couch.

Beth continues to play the role of her mother.

Mixup!

A playful costume switch has unpredictable consequences.

Your sexy mom at 75 is never too old to be fucked.

At first he loved her, but now he just wants to fuck :)

Emily's and Stephanie's date escalates.

Found my mom at a swing club.

Taken at the club.

A case of mistaken identity goes terribly right.

Confusion and mistaken identities lead to love.

Son in disguise tricks his alcoholic mother into having sex.

Kim learns the man she is webcamming with is daddy.

Young girl meets her father for the first time.

The gang was supposed to do it to his wife.

She disguises herself as a guy - and finds true love.

A case of mistaken identity, then brother pushes his luck.

Things go wrong when twin sisters switch places.

Jason received a mysterious invitation to a masquerade ball.

A woman is attacked while walking home from a night out.

Daughter is desperate to seduce her dad, whatever it takes!

Brother's plan to get back at sis succeeds big-time.

Which friend has the cheating wife?

Sister moves in temporarily.

Our daughter was in an accident and I found out...