‘mistaken identity’ stories

Sister helps son and mother grow close once more.

He gets mistaken for his sister! Disaster ensues!

Late night drunk girl neighbour visits.

Sometimes you get what you wish for.

Husband's uncut twin tricks her into sex.

Being a pizza boy can be a ... complicated profession

A husband finds that online chats aren't all that they seem.

Sally plots incestuous revenge on her twin sister.

Angela and Alison trick their crushes into having some fun.

The neighbor's cock is just too good to resist!

Trevor's day worsens.

Pakistani milf Bablee is fucked by her daughter's boyfriend.

Katie enjoys fucking a masked stranger at a Halloween party.

Exploring some taboos.

Ryan escapes his wife at a nightclub and discovers something.

Time to talk.

A Halloween party serendipitous connection changes Gabby.

Conversion by mistaken impression.

A young man makes a daring move on his crush.

Her husband makes her think there is another man.

Group makes college & family life fit together.

A medieval fantasy filled with love, lust and treachery.

A billionaire, a thief, an abduction, and a kiss...

Costume party makes man question his sexuality.

How far will Joelle go to save her college career?

Carly gets ridden by her neighbor.

Costume party gets out of control.

Even under-the-table jobs have benefits.

Velvet didn't expect me home early.

Literotica writer's wife gets the wrong end of several sticks.

A mountain lodge getaway weekend turns problematical.

Blindfolded guy thinks it's his girlfriend, but...

A warning to a certain Literotica Author.

Lisa discovers why her daddy wouldn't let her go.

Mr. Marcus sends Zeke as substitute to party in costume.

Handmaiden versus Tusken Raiders!

Intentional exposure again has unexpected consequences.

Gay virgin mistakes her for a man.

Shrodinger's Cat: In the dark, all kitties are the same color.

Simon celebrates NYE with his wife...or is he tricked.

Naughty wife hits the steam room.

Redhead finds excitement and confusion online.

Blind date with the wrong man.

The beautiful sister goes and her sister appears frumpy

A ravishment fantasy goes awry.

Halloween costume party leads to mistaken identity.

A costume party, a wrong address, a case of mistaken ID.

Julia has doubts about her doctor.

Father-in-law doesn't know it's her.

Charlie corrects Mrs. Hendricks' first time.

A sexually frustrated couple attend a costume party.

Dynamite Twins.

Wife lends husband a helping hand.

To get her man, Penny competes with a naked girl.

Casandra and Madison switch places.

Massage goes too far, and a woman must be satisfied.

A surprise in the park might be even more of a surprise.

There couldn't be a mix up with the costumes - could there?

College, the best time of your life!

Jo goes to dinner with friends.

An invitation to a swingers party turns into sex with her parents.

How she accidentally gave her husband's boss a blow job.

Lucy and her best friend play a trick on her Dad.

You can't win a shell game, even when played with costumes.

Behind a mask, Eleanor tricks & seduces her coworkers.

The MILF next-door mistakes you for your dad from behind.

She loves him, but he loves...

Man with amnesia satisfies retired ladies.

Claire's Journey continues with one slutty day.

Ed brags that he can always tell his wife and her twin apart.

Maureen makes a mistake in the garage.

Don't I know you from somewhere?

Craigslist post makes for an interesting situation.

Step daughter Takes Over.

Jeannie discovers light bondage and stranger fantasy.

An industrial baron is tricked into something fun.

Maybe blondes really do have more fun.

At least that's what I thought I was there to do.

A little restraint turns into fun for Barbie.

Young wife has a day!

The Magic Show : how it all began.

Masquerade party at the swing club: will the wife go?

The thrilling conclusion of Lucy's incredible adventure!

When a Catholic man meets his family in law.

Mistaken identity, sex, tears.

Sally trades places with her sister.

A desperate woman and a case of mistaken identity.

(but not in the bagging area...)

A double switch!

Jan's sister Jean gets a surprise from the doctor.

Don has Sex on the Beach; Alice and cousin play; fucking Meg.

Bacchus's Delight: The After Party

Mistaken Identity.

The Visitation; Hannah receives Holy communion.

The Unconquered meets his Agate - fourth among his harem!

An April Fool's joke takes an unexpected turn.

Wife finds out he's an author; he find out she's a fan.

Hot sex on the Internet.

A BBW overides her self pity by riding a man

Something's gotta give.