‘mistaken identity’ stories

Active tags
sister (21)costume (19)brother (17)mother (17)daughter (17)halloween (16)stranger (16)incest (16)drama (14)accidental incest (14)father (13)son (13)milf (13)cheating (12)oral (11)party (11)threesome (11)mother son incest (11)mask (11)anal (11)18-year-old (10)blowjob (10)blindfold (10)coed (9)college (9)mother son sex (9)brother sister sex (8)voyeur (8)reluctance (8)bondage (8)romance (8)hot wife (8)brother sister incest (8)revenge (7)surprise (7)romance novella (6)forced (6)older woman (6)cuckold (6)friends (6)bdsm (6)father daughter incest (6)father daughter sex (6)gay anal (6)tricked (6)big cock (6)first time (5)redhead (5)tease (5)younger man (5)adultery (5)orgy (5)lesbian (5)female masturbation (5)siblings (5)masturbation (5)seduction (5)older man (5)blonde (5)accident (5)drunk (5)creampie (5)female submissive (4)reluctant (4)anal sex (4)oral sex (4)humor (4)interracial (4)swingers (4)slut (4)exhibitionist (4)male dominant (4)public sex (4)best friend (4)deception (4)costumes (4)friendship (4)younger woman (4)lesbian incest (4)twins (4)accidental (4)fingering (3)costume party (3)stepfather (3)swap (3)teacher (3)masquerade (3)hotel (3)wife (3)pregnant (3)blind date (3)gang bang (3)18 year old (3)christmas (3)sleeping (3)virgin (3)love (3)brunette (3)outdoors (3)voyeurism (3)group sex (3)impregnation (3)girlfriend's friend (3)cheerleader (3)sisters (3)jealousy (3)noncon (3)blow job (3)lesbian sister (3)aunt (3)mature (2)big dick (2)big tits (2)incest oral (2)black woman (2)anonymous (2)schoolteacher (2)submission (2)internet (2)upskirt (2)white man (2)cunnilingus (2)stepdaughter (2)mistake (2)indian wife (2)santa (2)lingerie (2)co-worker (2)amnesia (2)doctor (2)cruising (2)nonconsent (2)family (2)female virgin (2)cop (2)stockings (2)sharing (2)shemale (2)outdoor sex (2)brother sister (2)humiliation (2)mom (2)mmf (2)transsexual (2)swapping (2)spanking (2)professor (2)india (2)exhibitionism (2)examination (2)fantasy (2)blackmail (2)beach (2)swinging (2)big ass (2)lesbian first time (2)female crossdresser (2)indian (2)fucking (2)handcuffs (2)toys (2)public (2)harley (2)high school (2)group (2)kidnapped (2)hairy pussy (2)first anal (2)incest romance (2)groping (2)incest anal (2)sibling sex (2)friend's boyfriend (2)bisexual female (2)historical (2)infidelity (2)cheating wife (2)brother in law (2)young guy (2)disguise (2)erotic drama (2)ravishment (2)case mistaken (2)light bondage (2)femdom (2)sister-in-law (2)foursome (2)embarrassing (2)kissing (2)michael parents (1)being watched (1)fantasy fulfilled (1)taboo (1)rimming (1)grew tired (1)bar pick-up (1)bisexual (1)true love (1)drunken uncle (1)runner (1)male virgin (1)adventure (1)slave (1)alien sex (1)transvestite (1)swollen breasts (1)royalty (1)a night of sex (1)gay drama (1)gay male (1)monster cock (1)yeah bitch (1)ski resort (1)tryst (1)swinger club (1)web cam (1)incest drama (1)father in law (1)stomach flu (1)cowboy (1)secret santa (1)female dominance (1)sex with stranger (1)mix up (1)handjob (1)big butt (1)blackjack (1)circumcision (1)sex money (1)gay hunk (1)milf sex (1)nailing the party hostess (1)porn (1)
mistaken identity

Tuning Her Piano

At least that's what I thought I was there to do.

Mature 11/21/2017

Sharing a Bed with Little Sister

Accident happens when two siblings share a hotel room.

Incest/Taboo 11/15/2017

Every Dick Has Its Day

College guy with a small dick fucks & satisfies four hotties.

Erotic Couplings 11/13/2017

New Year's Party Favors Ch. 01-03

An industrial baron is tricked into something fun.

Group Sex 10/23/2017

Gaming: D&D Pt. 04

Sometimes you get what you wish for.

Novels and Novellas 10/08/2017

Daddy's Cock Forever!

Father of the bride makes daughter his slut.

Incest/Taboo 10/07/2017

Camping with My Girlfriend and Family

Sometimes animal instincts takeover - even when it's mom.

Incest/Taboo 10/04/2017

TT2: Becky's Debt Ch. 03-04

Becky, Brody, & the cowboys' brothel.

Novels and Novellas 09/27/2017

Jackson Hole

Motorcycle trip turns into an unintentional swap among friends.

Loving Wives 07/23/2017

Bablee Ch. 02

Accepted as a schoolgirl.

Fetish 06/21/2017

The Boat That Rocked. A Fantasy.

Literotica writer's wife gets the wrong end of several sticks.

Loving Wives 06/08/2017

Mistaken Identity

College, the best time of your life!

Group Sex 06/07/2017

Table for Two Ch. 02

Emily's and Stephanie's date escalates.

Incest/Taboo 04/10/2017

Table for Two

A straight girl accidentally has sex with her own sister.

Incest/Taboo 04/02/2017

Pranking the Distance

Gina pranks fiancé, but can't stop what she set in motion.

Group Sex 03/17/2017

Substitute for Blindfolded Wife Ch. 02

Can Lacey ever get over the deception?

NonConsent/Reluctance 03/17/2017

Light's Out Party

The party's pitch black, and it could be anyone...

Incest/Taboo 02/27/2017

Mistress Esmeralda

A man meets a Dominatrix in a very cold place.

Humor & Satire 02/17/2017

Peter Priper Ch. 05

Do not trust the genie in the bottle.

Humor & Satire 02/14/2017

How I banged My Lesbian Sister

Mark finds his lesbian sister nude and blindfolded.

Incest/Taboo 02/04/2017

My Sister and her Cheerleader Friends Ch. 05

Discovery & his sister... finally!

Incest/Taboo 01/26/2017

My Sister and her Cheerleader Friends Ch. 01

Darren's sister and her friends stay the week.

Incest/Taboo 01/22/2017

The Case of the Mistaken Identity

A sexually frustrated couple attend a costume party.

Fetish 01/06/2017

The Sins of the Fathers Ch. 19

Shrodinger's Cat: In the dark, all kitties are the same color.

Incest/Taboo 10/13/2016

The Other Side - Sleepy Breeding

He likes impregnating sleeping girls.

NonConsent/Reluctance 09/20/2016

Chad and Jen...and Joy

Sister moves in temporarily.

Incest/Taboo 09/19/2016

Pizza Boy Delivery

Being a pizza boy can be a ... complicated profession

NonConsent/Reluctance 08/05/2016

Dan the Man

A country guy migrates to the city to find great sex.

Erotic Couplings 08/04/2016

Wrong Room

My roommate's girlfriend gives me a blowjob by mistake.

Erotic Couplings 06/17/2016

After the Block Party

Taken at the club.

NonConsent/Reluctance 05/10/2016

Bitsy's Inhuman Submission Ch. 17

Bacchus's Delight: The After Party

BDSM 04/12/2016

Bitsy's Inhuman Submission Ch. 16

The masquerade ball.

BDSM 04/10/2016

Sensualist Pt. 02 Ch. 05

Thoughtful considerations followed by fucking Ruth.

Erotic Couplings 01/31/2016

The Princess and the Villain

Felix attempts to stop his sister from making a mistake.

Incest/Taboo 01/21/2016

Spring Break Surprise

A son walks in on his mother wearing only an apron.

Incest/Taboo 12/30/2015

The Reluctant Schoolgirl

A young woman is mistaken for her younger sister.

Fetish 10/20/2015

Fooling April

My brother is a jerk, so why does he get a smoking hot girl?

Erotic Couplings 10/16/2015

Halloween Trick or Treat

Swinger party with a twist.

Incest/Taboo 10/16/2015

My Pink Plaid Shirt

A crush, a friend, and a bachelorette.

Lesbian Sex 10/10/2015

Truth or Dare

Mother and Son play truth or dare in front of her friends.

Incest/Taboo 10/08/2015

He Never Remembers

Short Term Memory loss victim visits nursing home.

Mature 09/01/2015

Jenny and the Landlord

Mistaken identity, sex, tears.

Group Sex 06/08/2015

Masquerade Party

Mother and son unknowingly meet at a party.

Incest/Taboo 05/23/2015

The Unfair Exchange

How far will Joelle go to save her college career?

NonConsent/Reluctance 05/02/2015

More than a Substitute

A single dad meets an extra-friendly preschool teacher.

Romance 03/30/2015

Be Sure What You Plan For

Was it fun for husband?

Loving Wives 03/17/2015

Goodbye, Miss Granger Ch. 11

FINAL: Trapped and naked, Jeannie's mistaken identity fantasy.

Erotic Couplings 03/07/2015

Goodbye, Miss Granger Ch. 08-09

Jeannie discovers light bondage and stranger fantasy.

Erotic Couplings 03/01/2015

Goodbye, Miss Granger Ch. 01

Schoolteacher's mistaken identity / stranger fantasy begins.

Erotic Couplings 02/12/2015

The White Rose Crisis Ch. 03

Will investigates: love, lust, and a confrontation.

Incest/Taboo 11/29/2014

Russell's Sinful Christmas

Mom and Aunt must act to save him.

Incest/Taboo 11/11/2014

Halloween Trick, Treat, Nightmare

She gets a trick, I get a treat and we both get a nightmare.

Incest/Taboo 11/10/2014

Family Get-together

A crowded house causes a big problem.

Incest/Taboo 10/26/2014

Bella's Halloween Treat

Bella and her daddy have a Halloween party accident.

Incest/Taboo 10/20/2014

Switched Up Costumes

A Halloween party costume change becomes interesting.

Erotic Couplings 10/02/2014

Missed Connections

Craigslist post makes for an interesting situation.

Erotic Couplings 09/14/2014

American Mom Ch. 08

Francine Plans a Surprise.

Incest/Taboo 09/06/2014

Sensualist Ch. 10b

Don has Sex on the Beach; Alice and cousin play; fucking Meg.

Erotic Couplings 08/29/2014

The Polar Bare Club

To get her man, Penny competes with a naked girl.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 08/06/2014

More than Friends: Ch. 05

Time to talk.

Romance 07/26/2014

More than Friends: Ch. 04

Something's gotta give.

Romance 07/19/2014

More than Friends: Ch. 03

Edward sees Janice in a new light.

Romance 07/12/2014

Special Needs

A mature wife struggles to care for a "special needs" guest.

Mature 07/09/2014

More than Friends: Ch. 02

She loves him, but he loves...

Romance 07/05/2014

More than Friends: Ch. 01

Longtime friends fall in love.

Romance 06/28/2014

Finding the Line Between Love & Hate

A compulsive liar fights to break herself out of her lies

Romance 05/26/2014

The White Rose Crisis Ch. 02

Will freaks out in the aftermath of Sarah's wedding

Incest/Taboo 05/22/2014

Transformation Ch. 05

Transformed into a female, Sara has to adapt to her new life.

Sci-Fi & Fantasy 05/21/2014

The Interview

He came for the job...

Gay Male 05/14/2014

Bounty Hunter Ch. 05

A bounty hunter captures an elusive criminal, or does he?

NonConsent/Reluctance 03/20/2014

Another Class Reunion

Identical twins change places for the evening.

Loving Wives 03/16/2014

He Didn't Hear What I Said

Miscommunication leads to mistaken fucking.

Loving Wives 02/21/2014

Bounty Hunter Ch. 04b

A bounty hunter captures an elusive criminal, or does he?

NonConsent/Reluctance 12/15/2013

Bounty Hunter Ch. 04

A bounty hunter captures an elusive criminal, or does he?

NonConsent/Reluctance 11/29/2013

Bounty Hunter Ch. 03

A bounty hunter captures an elusive criminal, or does he?

NonConsent/Reluctance 11/12/2013

Bounty Hunter Ch. 02

A bounty hunter captures an elusive criminal, or does he?

NonConsent/Reluctance 10/28/2013

Bounty Hunter Ch. 01

A bounty hunter captures an elusive criminal, or does he?

NonConsent/Reluctance 10/18/2013

Tricking Twin Sister

Brother in costume fucks all 3 of his bitch sister's holes.

Incest/Taboo 10/02/2013

Friendly Loving Joint Indian Family

A family of I, my wife and my friend.

Loving Wives 09/06/2013

Gavin Screws Up Ch. 03

Ellie goes to a sex club in an attempt to forget him.

Group Sex 07/27/2013

Soap On A Rope - The Aftermath

What happens in Vegas stays in Vegas. Or does it?

Loving Wives 07/01/2013

The White Rose Crisis Ch. 01

So many girls...but who could it be?

Incest/Taboo 06/21/2013

The TSA Office

Man strip searched and more in a case of mistaken identity.

BDSM 02/17/2013

I Lost His Number

She found him, lost him, but he didn't get far.

Romance 02/08/2013

Park Gang Sorta Bang

A surprise in the park might be even more of a surprise.

Gay Male 11/19/2012

Mistaken Identity at the Beach

Where does a mistake end and cheating begin?

Loving Wives 11/17/2012

Sharing Toys

Wife sends house guest into my bed.

Loving Wives 11/17/2012

Oh Santa!

The girls' Christmas party.

Erotic Couplings 11/17/2012

Blindfold Trick

A son takes advantage of his mother blindfolded on her bed.

Incest/Taboo 10/29/2012

The Phantom

Katie enjoys fucking a masked stranger at a Halloween party.

Loving Wives 10/19/2012

The Bra Salesman

A man is mistaken for a lingerie salesman by a busty woman.

Humor & Satire 10/12/2012

Halloween Swap

Mr. Marcus sends Zeke as substitute to party in costume.

Erotic Couplings 10/10/2012

Shell Game

You can't win a shell game, even when played with costumes.

Erotic Couplings 10/03/2012

Masquerade Marriage

Masquerade party at the swing club: will the wife go?

Loving Wives 09/30/2012

Masquerade Madness 02

Lisa discovers why her daddy wouldn't let her go.

Incest/Taboo 09/12/2012

Bachelor Party Paranoia

A warning to a certain Literotica Author.

Loving Wives 07/25/2012

A Gift Amongst Friends Ch. 03

Mandy begins to lose control as situations escalate.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 07/13/2012

Ryan and Hayley

Ryan's friends trick him into fucking his younger sister.

Incest/Taboo 06/11/2012

Teacher Is Mistaken

Hollie is mistaken for a student.

NonConsent/Reluctance 05/20/2012

Field Trip Follies Ch. 09

A sexy high school teacher is caught in a web of sin.

Novels and Novellas 05/14/2012
Active tags
mistaken identity
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ
Related Tags