‘mistaken identity’ stories

The Visitation; Hannah receives Holy communion.

He fulfills her fantasy - or does he?

Jack is shocked to his core.

Trick and treat again and again.

He came for the job...

busty scientist becomes lab animal in her own experiment.

Becky, Brody, & the cowboys' brothel.

Emma's bondage plan for Abigail goes a bit wrong.

A compulsive liar fights to break herself out of her lies

Accepted as a schoolgirl.

A costume deception leads to new experiences.

Coed tries light bondage with her boyfriend.

Who is he, & why are his memories coming back to haunt him?

Mistaken identity brings two together.

She dresses as Freddy Krueger to pick up girls.

I gave up drinking for a good reason.

A tale of mistaken identity and lust.

Grace goes to the wrong address for a blind date...

Our three intrepid heros are stranded on a desert island.

The rest of the story.

Danni Ash look-a-like falls into Deputy Duffy's hands.

Peter gets a surprise.

Mistaken identity leads to an unexpected coupling.

Has the absconded con man been caught?

A young man dares to enjoy the lives of his doppelgängers.

Cynthia was a married woman.

Life goes on.

Tutor is lured to a party she knew to avoid.

Who snuck into Danny's bed?

A mistake became an encounter.

Casandra and Madison switch places.

A date in the sculpture gardens has an unexpected result.

Horny headmaster threatens Mandy's Parisian education.

Casandra and Madison switch places.

Barb gets a million dollar proposition.

Edward sees Janice in a new light.

Thoughtful considerations followed by fucking Ruth.

Marie signed up for a CNC but gets more than she planned.

Her teacher ignores her in class but texts her at night.

Samantha gets back at the man who killed her mom.

Vengeance is a killer.

The Princess and the Pauper: a case of mistaken identity.

Reo takes a girlfriend's ass in a case of mistaken identity.

A case of mistaken identity leads to an awkward encounter.

Sometimes the best-laid plans go pleasantly awry.

A clergyman unintentionally has sex with a parishioner.

Sexy Trina is brought into the plan.

Casandra and Madison switch places.

A blind date gone wrong has got worse. But every cloud...

Mistaken identity leads to trouble for a Cat Person.

A case of mistaken identity.

Casandra and Madison switch places.

Debbie decides to use sex to earn money.

An apology letter for a husband's incestuous mistake.

A country guy migrates to the city to find great sex.

The beginning of the end, and a revelation.

Casandra and Madison switch places.

A case of mistaken identity.

She's intriqued by Trek fans, but they go too far.

Passerby assaulted during emergency planning exercise.

Enjoy stories of erotic mishaps in this fun themed contest.

A mix-up with control leads to great results.

The masquerade ball.

Into the mountains...

She makes a startling discovery.

She went to fuck an old flame....didn't she?

Do not trust the genie in the bottle.

Still in disguise, Eleanor pushes Kevin past his limits.

The bride finally loses her virginity - three times.

Ellie goes to a sex club in an attempt to forget him.

Behind a mask, Eleanor tricks Kevin into bed.

A (not so?) typical pick up scene at a bar.

Lewis finds that there’s even more of him about.

Lewis starts to tire of not being himself.

A man meets a Dominatrix in a very cold place.

Waylon's story continues.

"Scare" was in the air..

Now a Lewis lookalike takes advantage of his life…sorta?

True love, a ghostly curse, deception, & a plot for revenge.

Young woman gets a lesson in Internet dating.

The scheme climaxes as Trina meets Summer's husband.