‘gay first time’ stories

Skipping practice leads to fun in panties.

Mason takes Robert home to his apartment.

Adrian finds love in a small town after living in London.

Walking in on the boss leads to the start of something new.

Waking up at the Coleman house continues the adventure.

A fantasy of an older man being seduced into gay sex.

It happened, finally...

Seduced at my apartment gym.

My first encounter with an exciting man.

Friend's cock lingers in his thoughts, comes out as husband.

New to Los Angeles, a teenager is seduced by an older man.

I take Daddy and Eric's morning wood instruction.

Jess wants her boyfriend to have sex with another man.

Senior Quarterback Submits to the Cocky Freshman.

The bachelor gets unexpectedly dominated by his groomsmen.

A painful day at the beauty parlor and a photoshoot.

A crazy Vegas naked party gets humiliating for the groom.

The captain of the football team vs. the small slender boy.

The groom is out-gunned by his groomsmen.

New Quarterback Is Cocky in More Ways than One.

A tale from my past...about my first tail!

A former teacher is victimized by his younger bully boss.

Losing wrestler pays the price.

Best friend and horse-hung bros cement their dominance.

Big-dicked med student completely dominates my life.

Two straight guys trapped in the snow do what they must.

Best friends continue exploring.

A story of my first encounter with a man.

Straight live cam guy tries first gay blowjob to make cash.

Fun with hot, hung, aggressive Afghan bodybuilders.

Wild date ends at a glory hole.

Vengeance is a dish best served ice cold.

Late night gay encounter.

A Husband's Tale.

A neighborhood jog leads to first time magic.

Teen twin cousins play with me and my trans wife.

Two straight friends have anal sex.

Played a secret Santa

Continuing the story of Darren and Mark, now introducing Bao.

Young men experimenting.

A young guy newly addicted to BBC.

Nephew lies awake, thinking about his uncle, one room over.

Kelly tricks the brothers into gay incest.

Paul's first real blow-job and anal sex.

They learn the hard way to follow the rules.

Straight cowboy needs a man.

The hot guy from school is my new college roommate...

A story about two straight guys, who didn't see it coming...

Gay teenager's first time.

Avery confesses attraction to daunting male colleague.

Steve is caught and tricked in pleasing an older man.

Chad's first time gay and beyond.

A man, who is definitely not gay, gives a speech.

Kevin exploring gay lifestyle from straight.

The gang recovers, and tell stories about their first times.

Damian's inevitable return to Nevermore.

The Mustang man really has something . . .

Darcy moves in with an old friend after a long time away.

An intruder breaks into Bill's home and seduces him.

Drew and Autry meet on a cruise destined for disaster.

Nelson shows his coworker big things come in small packages.

Felix finally feels ready for his first time.

Ryan is fully converted.

Is he prepared to have his deepest desire fulfilled?

Ryan Jackson wakes up to more changes to his life.

Straight College Boy gets fucked and his world view changes.

Jack's wife is excited to hear about his first time.

A stranger sneaks into my room. Do I want him to leave?

After having a mmf encounter she forgets to pick up the order.

Morgan quickly returns to wrap up this unexpected adventure.

My first time getting filled up after years of fantasizing.

My history teacher takes me home and I taste my first cock.

I was the tight space that needed packing.

Losing my anal virginity.

Finally sucking my first cock.

Horse-hung roommate dominates me in private and public.

Naked modeling session shifts power dynamics in our dormroom.

My first sexual experience with a man. But not my last...

Straight Mark and gay Mark meet at a software course.

Best friend unexpectedly dominates me and my girlfriend.

Mature guy describes his first experience with another man.

There can only be one king of the locker room.

Sexy Italian teammate gets pounded in the sauna.

A young "straight" man has a new experience.

Jack's much needed release came from an unexpected source.

A group of friends take their bond to the next level.

My first time playing with an older guy on webcam.

Rower studs bet on who has the biggest dick.

The horse-hung stud dominates two teammates in the shower.

Straight, married man, experiences his first taste of cock.

The shortest lad in rowing dominates his sexy teammates.

Nathan get close to his new teammate.

Twice married and finds out he is gay.

Gay virgin mistakes her for a man.

Colleague takes advantage of intimate procedure.

Dominating a hot cop.

Conniving plans derailed when a hot ass gets drenched.

Mick learns about sex from an upperclassman.

Straight boy can't stop thinking about cock, gets surprise.

Matt begins to explore his sexuality more.