‘mistaken identity’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
mistaken identity 

Category

Black Tie Optional

A wife is told, "Just find your husband’s cock and suck it."

3.51
19.6k
23
0
58
0

Who's (Tied) Up For Lunch

A man, a wife, and a little self-bondage fun.

H
4.6
2.7k
6
3
19

Let's Put The 'X' in Sex

Sis gets inspired by KISS song after seeing bro with panties.

4.49
9.8k
20
1
73
0

The Den of Iniquity Pt. 04

Dennis comes up with an innovative new room at the Den.

4.04
2k
3
0
10

Getting Cable

A young transvestite exhibitionist lets the wrong man in.

H
4.7
4.6k
9
4
17
0

The Party - Ch. 01

Rebecca is fingered to the Jailhouse Rock at the Cinema.

4.39
8.7k
6
0
16
0

Crashed - The Conclusion

Our three intrepid heros are stranded on a desert island.

H
4.51
6.4k
9
2
13

A Fucked Up Situation

A mountain lodge getaway weekend turns problematical.

4.01
33.5k
30
13
85
0

What a Fucked Up Situation

A relaxing? trip to a mountain Lodge.

4.11
31.1k
38
25
97
0

Played the Fool

An April Fool's joke takes an unexpected turn.

4.25
12.5k
11
5
29
0

The Mistake

I gave up drinking for a good reason.

4.14
11.9k
10
1
28

Collateral Damage Ch. 02

Sister helps son and mother grow close once more.

H
4.68
15.1k
32
3
71

New Life At The Victorian Motel

Straight law student accidentally becomes lesbian prostitute.

H
4.59
26k
57
18
122

The Wrong Door

Mistaken identity when drunk. Daughter or wife’s room?

4.47
50.6k
113
8
213
0

NYE Party - Mistaken Identity

Simon celebrates NYE with his wife...or is he tricked.

4.48
12.2k
24
2
52
0

There's a Lot of Me About Pt. 04

Lewis starts to tire of not being himself.

4.56
1.7k
1
0
1

Revenge Backfires

Johnny seeking revenge on his sister backfires.

H
4.54
16.1k
44
7
80
0

There's a Lot of Me About Pt. 03

Now a Lewis lookalike takes advantage of his life…sorta?

H
4.71
1.7k
1
0
4

Parenthood

How does one recover?

H
4.67
76.8k
201
239
355
0

There's a Lot of Me About Pt. 02

Lewis finds that there’s even more of him about.

H
4.64
2.5k
1
3
3

There's a Lot of Me About Pt. 01

A young man dares to enjoy the lives of his doppelgängers.

H
4.53
10.2k
9
3
23

MILF-staken Identity

The MILF next-door mistakes you for your dad from behind.

H
4.72
21.1k
16
4
44
0

College Party & Mistaken Identity

Bro/sis accidental hookup.

H
4.65
71.9k
166
31
347
0

Which 2nd Ave?

Marie signed up for a CNC but gets more than she planned.

3.81
5.1k
5
0
20
0

Which 2nd St?

Grace goes to the wrong address for a blind date...

4.48
5.6k
10
4
22
0

Hannah's Science Adventures Ch. 01

busty scientist becomes lab animal in her own experiment.

4.22
9.2k
10
0
41
0

Property of 27

Tutor is lured to a party she knew to avoid.

4.28
8.9k
8
2
23
0

Kiss the Bride

Mistaken identity leads to more than a kiss for pretty bride.

H
4.5
43.9k
110
0
220
0

Unexpected Item

(but not in the bagging area...)

H
4.8
11k
13
9
29
0

The Kingdom Pt. 01

A medieval fantasy filled with love, lust and treachery.

H
4.82
8k
27
13
64
0

Irresistible Wife Ch. 02

An irresistible blonde wife left alone.

4.28
37.6k
49
5
104

An Unexpected Visitor

Late night drunk girl neighbour visits.

H
4.68
33.1k
32
7
67
0

Living with the Boltons Pt. 01

When a Catholic man meets his family in law.

4.41
14k
14
1
32

Does That Do It For You?

A case of mistaken identity leads to an awkward encounter.

3.68
11.9k
5
4
14
0

Mardi Gras Mistake

Wife mistakes stranger in mask for her husband.

3.77
38.2k
36
17
97
0

Split Second Thoughts

Things go wrong when twin sisters switch places.

H
4.76
56.4k
112
37
248
0

Welcome to the Neighborhood

The neighbor's cock is just too good to resist!

H
4.74
28.9k
31
2
54
0

Sister In Law takes my Wife's place

Maybe not incest, but definitively taboo.

4.08
75.5k
40
13
106
0

The Daddy Files: Kimmy + Rick

Surprised sleeping in Daddy's bed.

H
4.66
37.5k
100
3
185
0

The Daddy Files: Christine + Rich

Christine gets more than she bargained for. A lot more.

H
4.68
37.5k
105
3
199
0

The Best Weekend Camping Ever

Accidentaly fucking my aunt, and my mom thinks I am dad.

4.35
95.6k
102
8
199
0

Having Fun With My Aunt and Mom

Accidentaly fucking my aunt, and my mom thinks I am dad.

4.42
144.3k
177
17
339
0

The Perils of Mandy Ch. 02

Horny headmaster threatens Mandy's Parisian education.

4.36
8.6k
6
0
15

Wrong Place Right Time Ch. 01

Unexpected loss of virginity to a stranger.

4.44
36.2k
32
5
72
0

The Mommy Masquerade

Jason received a mysterious invitation to a masquerade ball.

H
4.63
55.8k
112
24
246
0

The Next Song You Write About Me

Toxic affair ends and he finds comfort with his sister.

H
4.59
26.6k
47
17
135
0

Between the Trees Pt. 01

A neighboring party goes wrong and Vic reaps the benefits.

H
4.62
54.5k
80
12
183

Dr. Zoptic Pt. 01 - Infallibility

Passerby assaulted during emergency planning exercise.

2.56
4.8k
4
0
16

My Best Friend's Drunk Wife

My best friend's wife gets drunk and crashes on my couch.

4.22
162.8k
144
39
278
0

Sister Forgot Her Key

Brother and sister love eachother very much.

4.1
57.5k
59
16
120

Valentine's Ghost

Miscommunication has deeper meaning for a lonely mother...

4.17
26.3k
48
4
109
0

A little Restraint

A little restraint turns into fun for Barbie.

3.97
13.7k
14
12
28
0

She's Mine Now

Surprised by his little sister at work.

H
4.57
70.6k
140
14
293
0

The Wrong Tent

He went to my tent by mistake, and I didn't stop him.

H
4.6
240.1k
434
47
793
0

Not So Old Wives Tale Pt. 01

Carly gets ridden by her neighbor.

4.49
28.1k
26
0
61

A Mishap of Circumstance Ch. 01

A Halloween party serendipitous connection changes Gabby.

0
19.6k
29
13
76
0

One Night, in a Motel

Father, Daughter bonding on a roadtrip.

4.36
124.1k
181
28
321
0

Crossdressing Son and Dad Pt. 03

Dad finally finds out the truth.

H
4.69
52.9k
66
5
100

The Halloween Hoax

Sophie counts on mistaken identity to get laid at the party.

H
4.61
32.9k
34
5
98
0

Charles in Charge Ch. 01

He gets mistaken for his sister! Disaster ensues!

4.28
30.8k
33
3
73

All of My Maids are Robots? Pt. 14

The thrilling conclusion of Lucy's incredible adventure!

H
4.69
5.3k
15
6
20

Tracked Down

Has the absconded con man been caught?

H
4.63
11.3k
8
7
14
0

Teaching Intent Ch. 02: Marge

Her teacher ignores her in class but texts her at night.

4.48
10.8k
5
1
22

I Don't Need a Father

Hannah meets her father for the first time.

H
4.56
67.2k
185
30
305
0

Drunken Love

Son in disguise tricks his alcoholic mother into having sex.

4.2
90.9k
118
4
228
0

Halloween Party with Mom

Found my mom at a swing club.

4.28
105.5k
123
9
249
0

The Octopie Creampuss

A costume deception leads to new experiences.

4.27
18.2k
10
0
38
0

Mom's Halloween Party

Julie has a plan, and it's going to involve some acting.

4.44
119.4k
101
13
216
0

Halloween Hook-up

A costume party, a wrong address, a case of mistaken ID.

4.21
40.2k
21
5
66
0

Debunked

A bunk bed, a mischievous roommate and a unsuspecting GF.

4.22
23.7k
39
2
86
0

Brenner's Lake Ch. 09

Who snuck into Danny's bed?

H
4.6
10.8k
8
1
25

Is It Really Her?

Life is full of surprises.

4.19
63k
58
70
105
0

Peach Picking Ch. 04

Ed brags that he can always tell his wife and her twin apart.

4.39
15.7k
17
5
43

Wrong Date, Right Time

Redhead finds excitement and confusion online.

H
4.58
19.6k
23
4
63
0

What I Wish Could've Been

A son sees nude and confessed to mother.

3.85
52.1k
39
8
81
0

Craving Daddy's Cock

Daughter is desperate to seduce her dad, whatever it takes!

4.49
96.3k
110
15
217
0

Abigail In Trouble Ch. 14: Cum, But Not Intruder Window

Emma's bondage plan for Abigail goes a bit wrong.

H
4.58
11.5k
10
6
19

Memory Lane

Sally plots incestuous revenge on her twin sister.

H
4.56
30.5k
31
7
99
0

The Upside

Helping my drunk neighbor back to her bed has its benefits.

4.34
240.3k
329
31
617
0

Daddy's Cock Forever Ch. 01-04

Mistaken identity shows daughter that Daddy's cock is best.

4.11
115.6k
149
5
330

Maria's Sis Gets a Turn

Mistaken identity leads Maria's sister to get pounded.

4.28
48.7k
52
0
125
0

May and the True Crime Novelist

May meets a true crime novelist for a blind date.

4.42
8.2k
11
3
26
0

Chasing Alex

A billionaire, a thief, an abduction, and a kiss...

H
4.69
13.1k
26
7
67

The Last Shapeshifter Ch. 02

Trevor's day worsens.

H
4.63
25.3k
30
5
51

Gas Station Guy

Gay virgin mistakes her for a man.

H
4.61
47.6k
24
22
65
0

Unconquered Pt. 10

The Unconquered meets his Agate - fourth among his harem!

H
4.87
9.7k
11
2
17

Needs

Bill has needs and goes looking for a blowjob from a hooker.

3.99
39.1k
35
3
91
0

Sunday Steam Room Surprise

Naughty wife hits the steam room.

4.41
33.9k
23
3
57
0

Horsing Around

Halloween party masquerade prank changes course.

4.46
37.7k
50
3
74
0

Halloween Surprise 2019

A mom mistakes her son for a stanger and puts on a sex show.

H
4.6
150.8k
210
11
357
0

Accidental Slut, A Halloween Party

Mistaken for brother's slutty wife.

4.23
201.2k
253
65
474
0

On the Hook

A husband finds that online chats aren't all that they seem.

3.78
74.5k
31
63
94
0

The Cinema

A young man makes a daring move on his crush.

4.21
30.5k
28
7
43

The Joke's on You

Angela and Alison trick their crushes into having some fun.

4.43
20.9k
31
2
87
0

Happiest Halloween

My costumed partner wasn't who she seemed...

4.45
193.1k
259
15
405
0

The Absurd Halloween Costume Party

Randomly assigning Halloween costumes causes grief.

4.09
52.2k
35
5
89
0
Active tags
Active tags
mistaken identity
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ